The Impossible Middle

Manager engagement just hit its lowest point in years. And if you think the answer is sending them on another resilience training, you've already lost them.

Here's what just landed: Gallup's 2026 data shows manager engagement dropped from 27% to 22% in a single year. Quite the dip.

And it's not because managers suddenly forgot how to manage. It's because the role has become almost structurally impossible.

The Numbers That Should Terrify You

Let's get specific about what's happening:

• 75% of middle managers report extreme burnout (Simon Sinek's Optimism Company, 2026). Not "feeling a bit stressed." Extreme burnout.

• 27% are actively planning to leave. Not thinking about it. Planning it.

• The average manager now has 12.1 direct reports (Gallup, 2026) — up 50% since 2013. Because organisations decided flattening structures would make them ‘agile’ while conveniently ignoring that managers are humans with finite capacity.

• Managers now spend less than half their time actually managing people. The rest? Putting out fires, usually ones that leadership started and sneakily backed away from. 

Oh, and here's the kicker: managers account for 70% of team engagement variance (Happily.ai). So when your managers burn out, the smoke reaches their whole team. One burned-out manager creates as many attrition risks as they have direct reports.

You don't have a manager problem. You have a manager crisis that's about to become an everyone problem.

But What Actually Broke?

Middle management has been redesigned into something no reasonable person can sustain.

• Bigger teams, same expectations. Span of control has jumped 50% in a decade. You can't have meaningful one-to-ones with 12 people. You can't coach 12 people. You can barely remember what 12 people are working on. But the performance targets? Those are still as fierce as ever..

• Accountability without authority. Responsible for engagement, retention, performance. But zero say in budgets, headcount, or the strategic decisions that directly impact all three. Managers are being set up to fail while being measured on outcomes they can't control.

• Enforcing policies they don't believe in. Return-to-office mandates they think are stupid. Restructures that make no sense. Performance systems that feel arbitrary. They're told to "cascade the message" while their teams watch them squirm and learn that honesty isn't safe here. (Check out what we had to say about this in our The Trust Freefall noones measuring article).

• Absorbing everyone else's anxiety. Management is worried about AI. Teams are worried about their jobs. Managers are supposed to implement AI with their teams while wondering if their own role disappears next. And they're supposed to do it all with a smile and a “growth mindset”, such fun!

• The cumulative effect of "do more with less." Every efficiency initiative, every cost-cutting measure, every optimisation lands on middle managers to execute. Eventually, the math stops working. You can't meditate your way through impossible workloads.

So the role of a manager basically has become impossible, and yet we just keep telling them to be resilient. If you're a manager reading this, how many of those boxes did you just tick?

The leadership pipeline is drying up

Only 25% of Gen Z professionals want to move into management (Robert Walters, 2026). They see what the role looks like in practice and decide it's not worth it. Your leadership pipeline isn't thinning, it's drying up. And turnover alone already costs $15 billion annually, before you count the productivity loss, team disruption, or the knowledge that walks out the door.

So What the F* is the solution?

If you're serious about fixing middle manager burnout — and really most organisations can’t afford not to be — then you’re looking at a fundamental redesign of how middle management actually works. 

1. Fix span of control

If your managers can't have a meaningful conversation with each of their direct reports at least once a week, they're managing too many people. Full stop.

Stop holding people accountable for outcomes they can't control. If managers are responsible for team performance, give them real authority over budgets, hiring decisions, and how work gets done. Because accountability without authority isn’t management, they’re messengers with a title.

2. Stop making them lie on your behalf

If you make a decision you know will be unpopular, own it. Give managers the real context — the constraints, the trade-offs, the actual reasons — and let them explain it in their own words.

And if a manager disagrees with the decision? Let them say so. Because teams can handle "leadership made this call and here's why" a lot better than "my manager is pretending this makes sense when we both know it doesn't."

3. Give them actual authority

Stop holding people accountable for outcomes they can't control. If managers are responsible for team performance, give them real authority over budgets, hiring decisions, and how work gets done.

And if you're not willing to do that? Stop blaming them when engagement tanks. They're not managing. They're messengers with a title.

4. Strip the administrative burden

Managers spend 10-15 hours per week on low-value admin work. We’ve worked with sales managers recently who spent 12 hours per week on CRM updates alone!

So ruthlessly redesign the work; What can be automated? What can be delegated? What can just stop?

5. Measure what matters

Track manager wellbeing the same way you track revenue. Regular pulse checks: Are you able to do your job well? Do you have what you need? Are the demands on you sustainable? What’s blocking you from being able to reach your goals?

Make the data visible and adapt roles so that they are actually doable. Because right now, we measure delivery but not burnout. 

Invest in development that fits the real role
Once you’ve been able to redesign a realistic role, then development becomes genuinely powerful. Not another workshop on having a difficult conversation, or being comfortable with ambiguity (yuk!), but real investment in skills managers need to lead well inside a structure that’s actually built for them to succeed.

That’s the difference between development as a sticking plaster and development as a genuine multiplier.

The organisations that get this right manage to both fix a burnout problem, and even better, they build a real competitive advantage; healthier retention, better performance, and a sustainable leadership pipeline that strengthens their future.

If you want to get serious about supporting your managers, and as you’ve made it this far we think you are, then get in touch!

If you enjoy both boat puns and great insight on all things People, Culture + Leadership, then sign up for our newsletter Unleashed Thinking. One email per month, no spam.